UT Watch on the Web

More Information

Other sources of information about the controversy surrounding the naming of the new molecular biology building at the University of Texas at Austin (UT) for Jim Bob Moffett, chairman of Freeport-McMoRan

  • Background Information N.B. "Irian Jaya" and "West Papua" are two names for the same place, the western half of the island of New Guinea, north of Australia. N.B. "TNI" is the post-Suharto name for the Indonesian military, which used to be called "ABRI".
  • AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE KINGDOM OF THE NETHERLANDS AND THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA CONCERNING WEST NEW GUINEA (WEST IRIAN). 1962.
  • Early Freeport contract negotiations with Indonesia for mining rights in West New Guinea. "As the first contract of work (1967) under the new Indonesian law, the agreement (the contract of work) broke new ground, Freeport's tax department helped the Indonesian government develop its system for taxing expatriates, something with which it had no experience, even opening its salary books so the tax office could get a general idea of the level of expatriate pay. The good relationship between Freeport and the Indonesian government also established the notion of the primacy of a contract, that the terms of a contract are not affected by future changes in, for example, the Indonesian tax code." From Grasberg: Mining the Richest and Most Remote Deposit of Copper aand Gold in the World, in the Mountains of Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia. George Mealey Publishers: Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold. ISBN 0-9652890-0-1. 1996. p. 86.
  • West Irian: Thousands of tribesmen killed. Michael Donald, The Observer, United Kingdom, June 1, 1969.
  • Indonesia: An act of Free Choice, Time Magazine, August 22, 1969.
  • Remarks by Dr. Ortiz Sanz. From: United Nations Document A/PV.1813, November 19, 1969, p. 21, paragraph 251. Part of a final report on organizing the "act of free choice" in West Irian in 1969.
      "I regret to have to express my reservation regarding the implementation of article XXII of the Agreement, relating to the 'rights, including the rights of free speech, freedom of movement and of assembly, of the inhabitants of the area'. In spite of my constant efforts, this important provision was not fully implemented and the Administration exercised at all times a tight political control over the population."

      Commentary by the National Liberation Council of West Papua, Poptahof-Nrd. 299, 2624 RN Delft, The Netherlands. Tel. 015-2613036, Fax. (15)-2613036. "It is known that Dr. Ortiz Sanz, the United Nations representative for advising, assisting and co-organizing the 'Act of Free choice' in 'West Irian' in 1969, was severely hampered in executing his tasks by the Indonesian government. He was not allowed by the Indonesian government to give advice, nor to assist and co-organize, as it was laid down in article XVII of the 'New York Agreement' of 1962. In addition, he was not allowed to take a large staff (50 people) to 'West Irian' because there was 'no sufficient housing available for those people', according to Indonesia. It was also known that the original content of his final report to the 24th General Assembly of the United Nations in 1969 was not accepted by the Asian Secretary General U Thant, because the wording of the report was too sharp and too negative for Indonesia. Consequently, great pressure was put on Dr. Ortiz Sanz to soften the wording of his final report. Despite this pressure Dr. Ortiz Sanz did maintain some of his original remarks in his revised report so that he was still able to express his criticism and regret openly. It has now become apparent that the appropriation of West Papua (New Guinea) by Indonesia, has been accompanied by all types of deceit and intimidation. Both the Melanisean people of West Papua (New Guinea) and the United National have been deceived."

  • 1993 - 1994, January 1995 - October 1995, November 1995 , December 1995 , January 1996 , February 1996 , March 1996 , April 1996, May-June 1996, July-December 1996, January-June 1997.

  • Rio Tinto reacts angrily to lodging of Freeport complaint. Asia Pulse, July 7, 1997. Lexis-Nexis. The Australian Mineral Policy Institute and the Australian Conservation Foundation have lodged a formal complaint against Rio Tinto before the Australian Securities Commission concerning statements made by Rio Tino's chairman about the environmental impact of the Freeport mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Rio Tinto owns about 12% of the mine.

  • Moffett Name Finally Unveiled: Spaw Glass Sign Removed. July 20, 1997. After four months of having been entirely covered over with a large tarp that said "Spaw Glass", the engraved sign high above the entrance to the new molecular biology building can now be seen to say "Louise and James Robert Moffett Molecular Biology Building".

  • New Toxic Materials Report. Drill Bits and Tailings, July 21, 1997. About two weeks ago, public disputes resumed in Indonesia about the nature of the "tailings", i.e., ground up rock, that the Freeport mine dumps into nearby rivers. Freeport continues to deny their tailings are toxic. Wahli, an Indonesian environmental group, continues to call for outside monitoring. For balance, the brief report cited in the previous URL ought to be supplemented by a pointer to a rebuttal Freeport is said to have made, but I do not yet have a URL for that. Freeport is reported to have stated in part "Walhi's statement is incorrect. Freeport does not use arsenic or cyanide in its mining process. The report represents a misreading of data on Freeport. A careful reading of these data, whether from Sucofindo, Bapedal (Indonesia's Environmental Protection Agency) or PTFI state clearly that tailings released into the Ajkwa River do not contain mercury, cyanide and arsenic."

  • IMC Global to acquire Freeport-McMoRan. Kim Tyson, Austin American Statesman, July 29, 1997, p. D1. According to the article, this $700+ million stock transaction will affect the phosphate fertilizer and sulpher mining parts of the Freeport empire, but not the part known as Freeport-McMoRan Cooper & Gold, which runs the mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua).

  • IMC to Buy Freeport-McMoran Inc. for $750 Million. Allen R. Myerson, New York Times, July 29, 1997. Lexis-nexis.
    • "Nothing, however, about Mr. Moffett and his businesses is ever simple."
    • "Yesterday, analysts and company spokesmen struggled to explain how Mr. Moffett's latest deal worked. Mr. Moffett was not available, and the companies' prime statement was a joint press release that in some cases juggled several different Freeport-McMoran entities in the same sentence."
    • "Yesterday's agreement is not binding, but the companies said they expect to have a definite agreement in a month and to complete the deal by the end of the year."

  • L'etat c'est moi. Forbes, 28 July 1997. The following commentary on a Forbes article comes from Carmel Budiardjo, tapol@gn.apc.org. "In a table headed, 'Kings, Queens and Dictators', Forbes lists the world's richest rulers, identifying the country, estimated worth, source of wealth and the year they came to power. The first two places are taken by the Sultan of Brunei, worth $38 billion, and King Fahd of Saudia Arabia, worth $20 billion. Next comes President Suharto with an estimated wealth of $16 billion, coming from stakes in major Indonesian firms. Trailing behind him come the rulers of Kuwait, United Arab Emirates, Saddam Hussein of Iraq, Queen Beatrix of the Netherlands, the Prime Minister of Lebanon, the King of Thailand, President Fidel Castro and Queen Elizabeth. The sub-heading reads: L'etat c'est moi. Businesspeople they are not, but they have accumulated great wealth - legally, extra-legally, and frequently illegally."

  • Equipment funding for molecular biology. Michael Crissey, Daily Texan, July 31, 1997. Of the $1.4 million available fund surplus from the operating budget recently announced for the next fiscal year at the University of Texas at Austin, $900,000 has been earmarked to pay for equipment for the Molecular Biology Program.

  • Court Rejects Amended Complaint Filed Against Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold. Freeport-McMoRan press release, August 8, 1997. Reports second dismissal of a federal lawsuit by Tom Beanal.

  • Tribesman must start over on suit. Stewart Yerton, Times Picayune, p. C8, August 9, 1997. Lexis-Nexis. Reports that despite a second dismissal, Beanal's lawyer Regan said he will revise the complaint according to the judge's order and file again.

  • Churchmen Reject Second Phase of Freeport 1% Trust Fund. August 19, 1997.

  • Churches in Irja Reject PT Freeport-Indonesia aid. Antara, Indonesia Daily News Online, August 19, 1997, via Carmel Budiardjo, tapol@gn.apc.org. "Jayapura, Irian Jaya (West Papua) - Leaders of three main christian churches here have rejected the financial aid from a trust fund set by PT Freeport Indonesia to assist tribal communities, saying it could provoke social tension. ... The giant mining company however has been the frequent target of human rights abuse allegations over the past two years."

  • West Papuan tribesmen block Freeport road. Reports of a disturbance near the Freeport mine, August 21, 1997.

  • Beanal vs. Freeport, Round III. August 21, 1997. Freeport Press Release.

  • Violence flares around Indonesian mine. Bernard Estrad, AFP, August 22, 1997. "At least one tribesman was shot dead and three soldiers wounded in fierce clashes between an army patrol and tribal warriors daubed in war paint in Indonesia's easternmost Irian Jaya (West Papua) province Friday, sources there said. ... The trouble early Friday flared on a road linking the town of Timika to the new complex at Kuala Kenchana, about 20 kilometres (12 miles) further north, when an army patrol clashed with a group of Papou tribesmen."

  • Indonesia: mystery over deaths in West Papua deepens. survival@gn.apc.org, August 22, 1997. Reports of more deaths and many beatings near the Freeport mine.

  • Timika: ABRI now in control after pacifying the people, Carmel Budiardjo, tapol@gn.apc.org, August 25, 1997.

  • Komnas HAM calls for postponement of Trust Fund disbursement. Kompas (Jakarta Newspaper), August 26, 1997. From a summary posted by Carmel Budiardjo, tapol@gn.apc.org.
      "The National Human Rights Commission (Komnas HAM) has issued a press statement about the Timika Incident calling for the postponment of the disbursement of the Freeport One Per Cent Trust Fund. This would help calm the anxieties of the local community and open the way for a review of the way in which the funds are used. Komnas HAM Secretary-General Baharuddin Lopa said: 'This would be a first step towards creating an atmosphere of mutual understanding in seeking a solution to the basic problems.'"

  • Knives Banned in Timika. Transmitted by Carmel Budiardjo, tapol@gn.apc.org, August 27, 1997. Here is the reply of the natives: How are we to hunt, and thus survive?

  • Amnesty International Urgent Action Request . Amnesty International has issued an "Urgent Action Request" about the recent deaths and beatings near the Freeport mine. (Incredibly, Amnesty is very picky about posting their stuff, even verbatim, stuff that it is ok to copy on paper. Complaints to ua@amnesty.org.uk.) August 28, 1997. This US appeal was soon withdrawn because the people were released.>
  • Freeport's take on the recent troubles. August 27, 1997.

  • Freeport expenditures, including charitable ones, in Irian Jaya (West Papua).

  • Timika problems are "complicated issues", Jakarta Post, September 5, 1997.

  • Minister: Freeport Fund Needs Review. Indonesia Times, September 5, 1997.

  • Proposition to Stop the 1% Fund for People Inappropriate, Suara Pembaruan, September 7, 1997.

  • Govt. enlists rogue corp against MUA. Report by the Australian Maritime Union, Sept. 11, 1997.
      International Purveyors is a front for Freeport McMoran, the mining giant allegedly involved in environmental plunder & human rights abuses in West Irian. International Purveyors, the company allied with the Howard Government in its war on the Maritime Union, is a front for Freeport McMoRan, infamous for its alleged desecration of Papuan sacred sites, environmental and human rights abuses.

  • Catholic Church on the 1% Deal. These very extensive remarks about relations between Freeport and the indigenous people of Irian Jaya (West Papua) were written by Brother Theo van den Broek, a spokesman for the Catholic Church in Irian Jaya (West Papua). He is an assistant to Bishop Munninghoff of Jayapura, whose diocese covers the whole of Irian Jaya (West Papua). Munninghoff retires, after 25 years, on September 14, 1997.

  • Update on the Situation in Timika, Irian Jaya (West Papua). Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Center for Human Rights, 3 September 1997.
  • Audit criticises giant Indonesian mine. Lexis-Nexis, Sept. 8, 1997. Comments on a report by the consulting company Labat-Anderson critical of the 1% solution.

  • Tension hurts mine fund; Study finds tribal problems defy company's best intentions. Stewart Yerton, Times Picayune, September 9, 1997. Lexis-Nexis. Also comments on the Labat-Anderson report.

  • Irian Jaya (West Papua) church leaders demand more human rights attention. AFP, Sept. 9, 1997. Lexis-Nexis. Report on statement by three local churches after the recent visit of Komnas Ham.
    • "The church leaders said the commission (Komnas Ham) could not possibly have gathered enough facts to find a solution to the series of conflicts that have mainly pitted the local population against a subsidiary of US mining giant Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold Inc. over the past two years."
    • "`The commission's attempt was insincere and incomplete upon investigating the long-drawn conflicts between the (local) people and Freeport as well as the internal conflict among tribesmen over the one-percent trust fund set up by Freeport,' the statement said."

  • Another riot, another crackdown. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Sept. 18, 1997. "The human rights situation in the villages near Freeport-McMoRan's huge gold and copper mine in western Papua, New Guinea continues to deteriorate. Last month, four Ekari tribal members were killed -- two in mysterious circumstances, two by gunshots delivered by Indonesian soldiers. Predictably, more unrest followed the deaths, provoking a further crackdown by the Indonesian military."

  • Mining giant is blamed for killings. Greg Roberts, Sydney Morning Herald, Sept. 19, 1997. "Indonesia's National Commission on Human Rights (KOMNAS) will investigate fresh allegations that staff of the American company that has been championed by the Australian Government in its push for waterfront reform were involved in the murder, torture and rape of villagers in Irian Jaya (West Papua). In a submission to KOMNAS last week, the Amungme Tribal Council accused Freeport Indonesia security staff of co-operating with the Indonesian military (ABRI) in the systematic abuse of human rights in the Timika area in the province's south-west. Freeport Indonesia is a subsidiary of the mining giant Freeport McMoRan."

  • Aid team, food for drought villages. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, Sept. 22, 1997.

  • Indonesian environmental catastrophe; Deaths in Irian Jaya. Sept. 20 - Oct. 30, 1997. The following observations are compiled from a number of press reports.
    • At least 507 people have died recently in Irian Jaya (West Papua) from drought related diseases, including cholera and malnutrition, a result of the worst Indonesian drought in 50 years, a drought attributed to El Nino. Another 300 are gravely ill. Most of the sickness is occuring in the Baliem Valley. Several hundred thousand people are now suffering food shortages. Residents of several villages are said to have only one week of food left.
    • Land clearing forest fires, which would normally have been controlled at this season by rain, have now created such an incredible haze throughout much of the gigantic Indonesian archipelago that much air and even sea traffic has become difficult-to-impossible. Somewhere between .5 million and 4 million million acres have burned, depending upon whose estimates one uses. The Indonesian government has ordered a complete stop to further clearing fires and has even apologized to neighboring countries for the haze. But with no rain in sight for perhaps months, it is hard to tell how bad the haze/drought situation will become. There are suggestions that the haze is reaching the Phillipines, Thailand, and Australia. 50,000 Indonesians are said to have sought medical attention because of the haze.
    • In the southwestern corner of Papua New Guinea, the famous Ok Tedi copper mine has now shut down because of the water shortage. The Fly River, a backbone for transportation of materials and from the mine, has shrunk to a dribble.
    • Some crops have failed in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Presumably because of the water shortage, some residents of the Baliem valley have consumed contaminated water and died.
    • Because of the haze it is even more difficult than usual to reach the many areas of largely roadless Irian Jaya (West Papua), such as the Baliem valley, that are generally only accessible by air, thus inhibiting both an accurate assessment of the deaths due to the drought and also the distribution of food, water, and medicine.
    • The Indonesian government is going to try seeding clouds to make rain. Ironically, it has been reported that some of the fires in Irian were set by natives who believe that smoke will cause rain.
    • Governments of the USA, Belgium, Britain, Germany, and Australia have issued travel warnings to tourists.
    • Utter speculation: there is some fear that the fire will ignite peat and lignite coal fires that could burn for years!
    • More speculation: the haze may have contributed to the mid-air explosion of an Airbus, killing more than 200.

    It is reported that there are also fires in the vast Lorentz National Park, which adjoins the Freeport mine area.

  • Cook lays down the law on arms; Indonesia export deal blocked. Michael White, Political Editor. The Guardian, 26 September 1997. Summary: The British government has blocked two licenses to sell arms to Indonesia out of fear that the weapons would be used for repressive purposes. This is a shift of policy against arms sales to Indonesia promised by the new government of Great Britain.

  • Komnas Ham endangered? Sept. 29, 1997. The BBC is carrying a report from the Indonesian newspaper Forum Keadilan that the Indonesian National Human Right Commission, Komnas Ham, will likely be disbanded, presumably for identifying too many human rights violations. Lexis-Nexis.

  • The Threatened Planet. Louise Williams in Jakarta and Mark Baker in Kuala Lumpur. Sydney Morning Herald, October 6, 1997.
    • " An estimated 200,000 people in Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore have been forced to seek hospital treatment for the effects of prolonged exposure to dangerously high levels of air pollution."
    • "An authority on peat forests, Mr Faizal Parish, who is executive director of the independent agency Wetlands International, based at the University of Malaya, says the damage already caused by the forest-fires in Indonesia may result in a 5 per cent increase in global greenhouse gases."
    •  

  • Tax dispute puts West Texas town in financial limbo: Freeport's stronghold. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Vol. 17, No. 5, Oct. 3, 1997.

  • Behind the Indonesian Veil; The truth about the American-run mine, Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s rebel conflict, and a seventh summit. Mark Bowen, Climbing magazine, Carbondale, Colorado, No. 171, Sept. 15 - Nov. 1 1997. A long article about climing, in 1995, near the Freeport mine. A reply by Freeport.
    • Contains a group photo with this caption: "... The man with the gun is wearing Freeport issue helment and windbreaker, and said he worked at the mine."
    • "The only way to tell the difference between (Freeport) security and the Indonesian military is that security carries AK-47s and the soldiers carry M-16s. Now, you don't have to worry too much about security; they're usually OK. But watch out for the soldiers. If they say, 'Jump,' you say, 'How high?' There are 65 of them in here, surrounded by hundreds of thousands of hostile natives. You can bet only the crazies got this assignment." The men in the room wore Freeport windbreakers. Some carried AK-47s. None wore anything to indicate they were soldiers.
    • "In many press releases (and even full-page ads in the New York Times), Freeport has repeatedly stated that its personnel do not carry guns. But I saw them carrying guns."
    • "We went from the squalor of base camp to the luxury of his modern condo in Tembagapura, literally "Copper Town," a community of 15,000 built by Freeport a few thousand feet below the mine, Tembagapura sits in a box canyon, looking down on dark chasms a mile deep, and up at steep green mountainsides that sprout scores of thin waterfalls whenever it rains. ... When we had showered, shaved, and filled our stomachs at a company mess, we sunk into the soft sofas in his living room to watch CNN and the Discovery Channel. Tickled to have a captive audience, he entertained us all evening with stories of his 11 years at the mine. He showed us promotional videos produced by the company, debunking them as we watched and laughing at the company's claim that the local water was drinkable. He related the latest incident in the perpetual conflict engendered by the presence of the mine: A few months before, he had been up working when his wife called from the condo to say that a brigade of half-naked Papuans was lobbing spears and shooting arrows from the perimeter - a metal fence about 75 feet from their door. Soldiers were in the living room, firing back from the balcony and windows with M-16s. ... "Keep your nose inside, dear, those are real bullets they're shooting," and went back to work. "Oh," he told us, "they'll probably attack again in six months. This place is a war zone. Used to be, whenever something like this happened, they [the soldiers] would fly over some village in a helicopter gun-ship and wipe it out with napalm. The soldiers would shoot tribals for sport and get pictures of themselves resting a foot on the chest or head of their kill, like trophy hunters. That's why you'll never see a Javanese outside the perimeter without a gun. The natives don't mind Americans and Europeans too much, but they hate Javanese."

  • Does a Starvation Disaster Loom for Irian Jaya (West Papua)? October 30, 1997. AFP reports that local officials are asserting that 500,000 Irianese (about 1/4 of the population of the province) will need food assistance to survive the drought-related famine in Irian Jaya (West Papua).

  • Starvation and Fires in West Papua. International Commission for the Rights of Aboriginal People.

  • Stricken villages gripped by famine. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald. December 8, 1997. The famine in Irian Jaya (West Papua) worsens.

  • 600 DIE AS DROUGHT CUTS FOOD STOCKS. Louise Williams. Sydney Morning Herald, Dec. 20, 1997. " The secretary of the Australian Red Cross, Mr Jim Carlton, said conditions were grim. 'This is the worst drought in Irian Jaya (West Papua) in living memory.'"

  • Fire Breather. John McBeth, Far Eastern Economic Review, December 4, 1997.
    • "Last February, an Indonesian military intelligence team filmed American human-rights activist Danny Kennedy lifting samples from the silt-laden Aikwa River in the lowlands of southern Irian Jaya (West Papua). Later, when Kennedy attempted to airfreight the vials of water to Australia, he was detained and quickly deported. His crime: conducting scientific research without proper authorization."
    • "Freeport is also forking out $35 million for barracks and other facilities for an 800-strong military task force the government brought in after anti-Freeport rioters rampaged through Timika and the high-altitude Tembagapura mining camp in March 1996. The Indonesian army recently assigned six armoured cars to Timika, which one activist now calls 'the most militarized district in Indonesia.'"

  • Feeding the politics of drought. Lee Rhiannon, Australian Financial Review, December 29, 1997. A sharp Freeport rebuttal. Describes the impact of the New Guinea famine in the area of the Freeport mine. "For the Amungme it is now virtually impossible for them to continue fighting Freeport as the drought has taken such a toll. Local people are severely weakened and in many cases are dying from hunger."

  • Jakarta rocked by 'junk bond' rating. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, January 2, 1998.

  • New Guinea starvation estimates raised. AFP, January 6, 1997. (It is probably a safe bet to double the estimates below to get an estimate for the whole of New Guinea, including the Irian Jaya (West Papua) half.)
      "More than a quarter of Papua New Guinea's population is now facing starvation because of the country's drought and the worst is yet to come, according to new Australian research. In December, the number of people badly affected by the drought doubled to more than one million from half a million three months earlier, the Australian Agency for International Development (AusAid) said in a report due for release Thursday. And one of the report's authors, who released details to AFP Tuesday, said that figure would jump again in the next few months, with the worst conditions expected in February and March. "

  • Forest fire at Owea causes tension within tribe. Report on tribal trouble near the Freeport mine. Down to Earth, January 28, 1998.

  • 1997 U. S. State Department Report on Human Rights in Indonesia.
    • Where indigenous people clash with development projects, the developers almost always win. Decisions regarding development projects, resource-use concessions, and other economic activities are generally carried out without the participation or informed consent of the affected communities. Unlike in past years, there were no reports that environmental NGO's that sought to aid these communities were subjected to verbal attacks, raids, and other forms of intimidation by government security forces.
    • Tensions with indigenous people in Irian Jaya (West Papua), including in the vicinity of a foreign mining concession area near Timika, continued. Indigenous Irian Jaya (West Papua) residents complain of racism, religious bias, paternalism, and condescension as constant impediments to better relations with non-Irianese people, including members of the Government, the military and the non-Irianese business community. They also complain of abusive behavior by the security forces. A large percentage of the population of Irian Jaya (West Papua) is now made up of migrants, who are economically and politically dominant. Most civil servants in local governments in Irian Jaya (West Papua) and other isolated areas continue to come primarily from other parts of Indonesia, rather than from the local indigenous population.
    • The anticipated distribution of funds from a foreign mining company created tensions that helped lead to a clash between tribal groups and security forces in August in the Timika-Tembagapura area, which led to the shooing deaths of two Irianese and injuries to security forces (see Section 1.a.). At about the same time, two groups supporting rival leaders of the Moni tribal group held demonstrations over their claims to part of the funds from the foreign mining company, and then later massed together near the office of the local district leader to press their demands. Credible NGO sources report that bystanders to this event were assaulted by security forces. Due to local protests over how the funds would be allocated, the company suspended disbursements for new projects under this initiative.

  • Freeport disputes human rights report. Stewart Yerton, Times-Picayune, February 4, 1998, p. C1, Lexis-Nexis.
      "A program started by a New Orleans mining company to help tribal people in Irian Jaya has contributed to tensions in the Indonesian island community, a new human rights report by the U.S. State Department says. The report also says the Indonesian government has ignored or been slow to react to a 1995 report on human rights violations in Irian Jaya."

  • Jakarta out lashes at "self-righteous" US rights report. AFP, February 6, 1998. Reports replies by the Indonesian government:
    • "It is inconceiveable that the United States feels privileged to continue to systematically target a number of developing countries like Indonesia as the violators of the human rights of their own people," a foreign ministry statement said.
    • "Publication of imbalanced and self-righteous reports containing inaccuracies, baseless accusation and heresies such as the State Department's report will only hamper efforts to promote and protect human rights and fundamental freedoms."

  • Government and Freeport to Resettle Many. Wolas Krenak, Suara Pembaruan Daily (Jakarta), February 2, 1998.

  • Report of PMI-ICRC joint operation in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Red Cross report on the desperate situation involving starvation and disease in the vicinity of the Freeport mine. February 13, 1998.

  • Call for action on the situation in West Papua. Reports on interference with efforts to save the starving. Tapol, February 24, 1998.

  • Indonesia causing disaster in PNG: flannery. Paul Sheehan, Sydney Morning Herald, March 7, 1998.
      The Indonesian Government is causing a secret catastrophe in Papua New Guinea, condoning murder, corruption, racism and environmental degradation, according to one of Australia's best-known scientists and authors, Tim Flannery. "The Indonesian Government is a brutal and totally corrupt regime," he said. "They are still shooting their blacks. We [Australia] have sold out to the worst form of colonial oppression."

  • State court case against Freeport to proceed. Times Picayune, March 6, 1998. "Though federal courts threw out an Indonesian tribe's lawsuit against Freeport-McMoran, a similar case filed in Orleans Parish will go forward, a state appeals court decided Thursday."

  • Ausaid report on drought in PNG.

  • Death toll rises in Irian. AFP. Jakarta, March 25, 1998. "Thousands of people have died and more are dying following a prolonged drought in Indonesia's remote Irian Jaya (West Papua) province, foreign aid workers said Wednesday. ... `The total number of dead will never be known' ... ... `There is a huge logistics problem.'"

  • Almost genocidal. Tapol, March 27, 1998.

  • Thousands starve to death in Indonesia drought. The Times, March 27, 1998, Lexis-Nexis.
      "THOUSANDS of people in Irian Jaya (West Papua), the Indonesian half of New Guinea, have died from starvation and malaria in the past three months, according to aid workers who have just left the region. Mortality levels have risen by more than 700 per cent in some areas of the Jayawijaya regency after an eight-month drought that killed off crops and provided fertile breeding grounds for malaria-carrying mosquitoes, one Western aid worker reported. `It's much worse than people have been led to believe. At least 6,000 people have died and more are dying every day.'"

  • Indonesia: Gold, Greed and The Future of Capitalism, Michael Paterniti, Rolling Stone, April 30, 1998, pp. 45-52. Long article on Freeport's mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua).
    • "'Moffett thinks of us as animals ... But he was born naked, like me. He is not a god; he just has a lot of money.'" Tsenawatme of Lemasa.
    • "Does a company doing business with a corrupt government bear any responsibility for the lawless acts of a lawless regime?"
    • "'The majority agreed that we should not let this guy (Paterniti) in, but we need a valid reason,' he (Freeport VP Vice-President Robinette) writes, 'Our intelligence research showed no reason that we could use to keep him out ... Barring a reporter because we don't like his publication or his personality leaves us open to the charge that we allow only those in who we think will be pro-Freeport.'"
    • "... Timika, a boomtown of 35,000 people that has become the main staging area for Grasberg, will be burned to the ground ..." Paul Murphy quoting Tom Beanal from an Indonesian paper.

  • Business as Usual? Irian Jaya (West Papua) Killings Detailed in New Report. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Vol. 17, No. 34, May 1, 1997.

  • Australia to the rescue. Early May, 1998. Compiled from various press reports. Australia is spending about $6 million (US) to support Australian military operations to deliver food in the vicinity of Wamena and the Baliem valley. Included in the relief effort are 3 Black Hawk helicopters for delivering food and 2 C130s to ferry fuel for the helicopters, all manned by Australian military folks. This humanitarian effort follows upon a similar Australian effort, months ago, to relieve starvation in neighboring PNG, also caused by El Nino. (God bless the Australians. Is it time to rethink colonialism?)

  • Student deaths. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, May 14, 1998. Eyewitness account of the murder of students by the Indonesian military.

  • Freeport resettles 300 families. Jakarta Post, May 13, 1998. Lexis-Nexis. "Mining company PT Freeport has resettled 300 tribal families living in its operational areas in Tembagapura, to a settlement area in Timika."

  • Indonesia revolts: 500 dead in Jakarta chaos. Sydney Morning Herald, May 15, 1998.

  • Freedom of the press, Indo-style. May 17 (AFP). "Indonesia's private television channels have been instructed to carry state-sponsored news programs that avoid depiction of the violence that has rocked the country this week, reports said Sunday. Instead of airing their regular early morning news programs, whose popularity has grown enormously since rioting and looting broke out in the capital and elsewhere in the country, the country's five private broadcasters have been told to broadcast state-sponsored news, the Jakarta Post said." (rsb: What further proof does one need that Indonesia's government is totalitarian? And not to be believed.)
  • Hunker Down and Go! Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Vol. 17, No. 36 May 16, 1998.

  • Suharto Resigns. Thursday, May 21, 1998.

  • BJ: Elections within a year. CNN, May 24, 1998.

  • Bintag amnesty. Jakarta, May 25, 1998, AFP. "President B.J. Habibie announced Monday that the Indonesian government had amnestied two prominent political prisoners, activist Sri Bintang Pamungkas and labor union leader Muchtar Pakpahan." ... "Pakpahan, chairman of an independent labor union, was serving a four-year jail term ordered in May 1996 for instigating a labor riot in North Sumatra. Bintang, chairman of the non-recognized Indonesian Democratic Union Party, was sentenced to 34 months jail in May 1996 for insulting then-president Suharto during a lecture in Germany."
  • Irian Jaya (West Papua): 137 dead in crackdown by army, says report. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, May 26, 1998.
  • Mercy mission: Airlift aimed at saving isolated villages. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, May 26, 1998.

  • How Indonesia's Army Fills a Power Vacuum: Military's chief of socio-political affairs reveals ideas on democracy, East Timor, Christian Science Monitor, Cameron Barr, May 28, 1998.

  • Letter from RFK Center on the recent report of human rights abuses in Irian.

  • AFP. AFP coverage of the new report about human rights abuses in Irian Jaya (West Papua), not far from the Freeport mine. May 29, 1998. 13 churches and 166 homes destroyed, 28 killed, 1,000 in hiding in caves and forests.
  • Hunker Down and Go! Robert Bryce, (an update to Hunker Down and Go! Austin Chronicle, Vol. 17, No. 36 May 16, 1998.) In Texas Observer, June 5, 1998, pp. 14-15. In response to Bryce's question at the shareholder meeting: "The Freeport executives described the loan guarantee as `typical business arrangements for situations when a minority interest owner is financing its investment in an entity controlled by a large majority owner.'"
  • Baptism of Fire. John Vidal, Guardian Weekly, May 31, 1998.

      Amungme tribal leader Yosepha Alomang, a mother of 10, should be in Britain. But as she boarded the plane this month in Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia, to head for London and the Rio Tinto annual meeting, she was stopped by the military. Had she come, Ms Alomang would have told the mining firm's corporate shareholders a harrowing tale of torture at the hands of the authorities. Four years ago she was imprisoned without charges, sexually abused and threatened with being shot. Held for a month in a filthy room, she was made to eat her own faeces.

      Ms Alomang is one of many outspoken critics of the huge Freeport copper mine, high in the mountains of Irian Jaya (West Papua), which is part-owned by Rio Tinto. For years the mine has been the centre of well-documented human rights violations against indigenous groups. It is also an example of an increasingly common trend that sees governments working in the interests of global corporations, against their own people. The mine subsidises the army by more than $30 million a year, and, like Shell in Nigeria or BP in Colombia, its owners distance themselves from atrocities carried out to "protect" its operation.

  • Death in Aceh. AFP, June 5, 1998. The Aceh Non Governmental Organization Forum claims that 40,000 people have been killed by the Indonesian military in Aceh province in recent years.

  • Hundreds of students in Jayapura demonstrate. Survial, June 5, 1998.

  • Freeport Indonesia yet to fulfill environmental pledge. Asia Pulse, June 16, 1998, Lexis-Nexis. "Indonesia's Environment Minister Panangian Siregar said on Monday the gold mining company, PT Freeport Indonesia, had yet to fully meet its environmental impact analysis agreement. ... Meanwhile, Anthonius Rahail, member of the House commission, said two million hectares of land owned by Freeport was reportedly polluted and affected the life of the local people. The company's wastes had also affected the woods around its operational area, he said."
  • Habibie announces human rights reforms. Jakarta. Karen Polglaze, AAP, June 25, 1998. Lexis-Nexis.
    • "`Stop the genocide' and `Halt the military operation' said the banners carried by the group of about 100 Irianese who were matched in number by armed troops."
    • "Spokesman for the Jakarta Irianese community, Hengky Joku, claimed 400,000 Irianese had been killed by the Indonesian military (known by the acronym ABRI) since Indonesia took over the province in the western half of New Guinea island in 1963. `This comes from claims from Irianese families,' he told reporters. `My father was the first one who was killed.'"
    • "The Irianese also called for the giant Freeport copper and gold mine in the southern highlands to be shut down. `Freeport causes death in Irian,' a spokesman for the Concerned Community Front for Irian said."

  • Shots fired in protest. Sydney Morning Herald, July 3, 1998. Recent independence protests in Irian. Warning shots fired.
  • Death in Jayapura. JAKARTA, July 3 (AFP) - "Two days of clashes between pro-independence demonstrators and security forces in Indonesia's easternmost province of Irian Jaya (West Papua) have left two dead and six others injured, witnesses and press reports said Friday."
  • Agent dies following student riots. Sydney Morning Herald, July 6, 1998. Report on trouble in Jayapura.
  • Troops killed Irianese separatists, supporters claim. July 7, 1998. Sydney Morning Herald.
  • Irian tribes defy slaughter. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, July 8, 1998.
  • Grim report on Irian. Survival, July 7, 1998.
  • Separatists Rally in Irian Jaya (West Papua); Top Indonesian General Calls Hoisting of Flag 'Treachery'. Reuters, Washington Post, July 8, 1998. "The official Antara news agency said Indonesian troops were trying to disperse thousands of protesters who had hoisted a separatist flag at the local parliament in Wamena town in Irian Jaya (West Papua), the western half of Papua New Guinea island."
  • Freeport suit to proceed; supreme court refuses to stop it. Times-Picayune, July 7, 1998, p. C1. "Louisiana's Supreme Court has refused to halt a lawsuit accusing Freeport- McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. of human rights violations and environmental damage associated with its gold mine in Indonesia."
  • Indonesians dismantle Irian separatists flag pole. Jakarta, Ian MacKenzie, Jakarta, Reuters, July 8, 1998. "Indonesian soldiers moved to cool off pro-independence demonstrations in Irian Jaya (West Papua) province on Wednesday by removing a protest rallying point -- a flag pole."

  • Freeport-McMoRan's Indonesian unit moves to quash corruption claims. Dow Jones Online New, July 10, 19998. Jakarta. "The PT Freeport Indonesia unit of Freeport McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc. (FCX), moved Friday to quash claims it benefited from corruption, collusion and cronyism under the regime of former President Suharto."
  • Trapped between tradition and tomorrow. Louise Williams, Saturday, July 11, 1998. "Irian Jaya (West Papua). Tribespeople in the remote province of Irian Jaya ... animosity towards Indonesian soldiers and bureaucrats runs deep. New protests this week by Irianese tribespeople against Indonesian rule erupted after years of simmering resentment."
  • Improper links?. Jakarta, July 10 (AFP) - "Chief executives of the giant Freeport copper mine in Indonesia Friday denied any improper links with ousted president Suharto. ... The executives, headed by President Director Adrianto Machribie, decried as `false and misleading' press reports which have implied that Suharto and his associates had improper links with the company."
  • PT Freeport denies any links to Suharto. Jakarta, Shoeb Kagda, Singapore Business Time, July 11, 1998. "Freeport, however, is the first company to publicly state that it had no dealings with the former president." (RSB: For nice photos of Suharto, see
    • Suharto "and Freeport Minerals president Forbes Wilson at the dedication of the Ertsberg mine in March 1973." p. 104 of Grasberg: Mining the Richest and Most Remote Deposit of Copper aand Gold in the World, in the Mountains of Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia. George Mealey Publishers: Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold. ISBN 0-9652890-0-1. 1996.
    • Suharto "and Freeport CEO Jim Bob Moffett at the celebratoin of inaugurating Kuala Kencan." p. 332 of Grasberg: Mining the Richest and Most Remote Deposit of Copper aand Gold in the World, in the Mountains of Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia. George Mealey Publishers: Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold. ISBN 0-9652890-0-1. 1996.
    • A picture from the front page of the July 13 issue of the Jakarta Post, in which Suharto pins the development medal of merit on the chest of Freeport-McMoRan CEO Jim Bob Moffett. Austin Chronicle, September 12, 1997.

      In Mealey, op. cit., p. 86 we read "As the first contract of work (1967) under the new Indonesian law, the agreement (the contract of work) broke new ground, Freeport's tax department helped the Indonesian government develop its system for taxing expatriates, something with which it had no experience, even opening its salary books so the tax office could get a general idea of the level of expatriate pay. The good relationship between Freeport and the Indonesian government also established the notion of the primacy of a contract, that the terms of a contract are not affected by future changes in, for example, the Indonesian tax code."

      See also Freeport and Busang. Also, "In February, Freeport won an agreement for developing the Busang field with Bre-X and a close associate of President Suharto's." NY Times, April 30, 1997. Also, "Freeport, through Mr. Moffett's connections with Indonesian President Suharto, was brought into the Busang project as mine developer and manager after a deal with Toronto-based Barrick Gold Corp. fell through." Ottawa Citizen, April 30, 1997.

      "Moffet arrived in Timika on Friday night after meeting President Suharto earlier in Jakarta." AFP, April 13, 1996.

      "Early this year, according to The Financial Times of London, a company that is 80 percent owned by 'foundations' chaired by President Suharto bought a five percent interest in the mine, Suharto's government has long owned nine percent directly." Mark Bowen, Climbing Magazine, Nov. 1, 1997.

      "At a recent dinner celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Asia Society (a nonprofit organization dedicated to fostering understanding between Asians and Americans), General Suharto was warmly introduced by one of his leading corporate patrons and beneficiaries, James Robert Moffett, the chief executive officer of Louisiana-based mining company Freeport-McMoRan." Eyal Press, Christian Science Monitor, Nov. 10, 1995, p. 19.

      Suharto "sees the Grasberg mine as the cornerstone of his eastern Indonesia development policy. The government has a 10% stake in Freeport Indonesia, with another 5% owned by Nusamba, a Suharto foundation run by presidential ally Mohamad 'Bob' Hasan." John McBeth, Far Eastern Economic Review, December 5, 1997.

      "The mine's future was reported to have been raised by President Suharto of Indonesia when he dined at the White House in late October." The Independent on Sunday, 26 Nov 1995, Janine Roberts.

      "On Thursday night, Indonesian President Suharto stopped in Washington for a dinner in his honor to benefit CARE, the relief organization. Moffett hosted the dinner. The next morning, Suharto called on President Clinton at the White House. A press release said that the talks focused on lofty subjects, including the Asian economy. But a senior Administration official acknowledged afterward that Suharto urged Clinton to make sure OPIC insurance would be preserved for Freeport-McMoran's Indonesian mining operations." LA Times, October 30, 1995. Includes photo of Suharto and Clinton.

      "Since 1983, Freeport's political action committee has paid members of Congress more than $730,000 for their favors. Louisiana's J. Bennett Johnston, the Senate's staunchest advocate of the Suharto regime and of US. oil and mining interests, got $8,000." ... "Jim Bob calls Suharto 'a compassionate man,' and indeed the dictator's tenderness for Freeport is such that he has seen to it that anyone who gets in the company's way is simply removed. About a month after the confrontation between the Amungme chief and the Freeport exec, 2,000 Amungme living near the mining site were ordered to leave their homes by the Indonesian government. It was a familiar action, one in a series of forced removals that began in 1967, when Freeport was granted the right to exploit Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s mineral resources." Eyal Press, The Nation, July 31, 1995. (Johnston is now on the Freeport board.)

      "While Bre-X, a small exploration company, has relatively little besides this project, Freeport-McMoran Copper and Gold is an old hand at Indonesian mining and investment. With close ties to the Suharto Government, the company has developed the world's largest copper mine and the third-largest gold mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua), another remote region, along the flanks of a dormant volcano." NY Times, April 29, 1997.

      "With close ties to the Suharto Government of Indonesia, Freeport-McMoran Copper and Gold has developed the world's largest copper mine and third-largest gold mine in that nation's remote Irian Jaya (West Papua) region." Allen Myerson, NY Times, July 29, 1997.

      "Following the shock announcement that US insurance company OPIC was cancelling Freeport's USD100 million policy against political unrest, it has been revealed that the Indonesian government lobbied hard against this possibility. Without mentioning its sources, Tiras says President Suharto asked President Clinton at their meeting 27 October to prevent the cancellation." Tiras, 16 November 1995.

      "The same company whose CEO describes Suharto as his 'partner' opts to make no comment about abuses committed by troops under Suharto's command." Eyal Press, Christian Science Monitor, Nov. 10, 1995.

      "Suharto visited Timika in early December to show his support for the embattled company." Far Eastern Economic Review. 25 January 1996.)

  • Amungme in court in NO. Drillbits and Tailings, July 7, 1998.
  • Freeport copper smelter project still on track. Jakarta Post, July 13, 1998.
  • Indonesia admits kidnap and torture. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, July 15, 1998.
  • Soeharto's links cast long shadow. Australian Financial Review, June 5 1998. "Obviously from the Freeport perspective there was a lot of upside in having the Indonesian President's family become direct beneficiaries of the Grasberg mine, which made a profit of $US245 million last year. One of those benefits became apparent last August when, just months after the Soeharto company had been financed into Grasberg, President Soeharto issued a decree which exempted PT Freeport Indonesia (the Grasberg mine operator) from paying Indonesian company tax. Freeport Indonesia was the only foreign-controlled company to be granted the tax exemption, worth tens of millions annually."
  • Belo accuses troops of rape in East Timor . Louise Williams, Syndney Morning Herald, July 17, 1998. "With East Timor braced for widespread anti-Indonesian protests today, the territory's spiritual leader, Bishop Carlos Belo, has accused the Indonesian security forces of systematically raping East Timorese women for more than two decades. Bishop Belo, leader of the Catholic Church in East Timor and Nobel peace laureate, told a seminar in Jakarta the security forces had used rape to terrorise East Timorese women since the military invasion of the former Portuguese colony in 1975. `If you ask me about rape, I am telling you the women of East Timor have gone through this since 1975 until now,' he said. Most East Timorese could never accept integration into Indonesia, he said, and the pro-independence guerilla fighters had suffered the rape of their wives and daughters."
  • Rape corset. Jakarta, July 19 (AFP) "Simon Ayasanjaya has struck it rich by patenting a modern version of the Victorian chastity belt -- but this one intended to guard against rapists not ease the fears of jealous husbands. ... Ayasanjaya told AFP he sold only a few hundred corsets after he put them on the market in mid-July last year, but that `after the tragedy in May' sales have shot up to around 5,000."
  • Freeport fails in court. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, July 23, 1998.
    • On July 2, the Louisiana Supreme Court ruled unanimously that Yosepha Alomang, an Amungme tribal member from Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia, may proceed with her tort claim against Freeport in state district court in New Orleans. The ruling means that Alomang's attorney in New Orleans, Martin Regan, may now subpoena documents and take depositions from Freeport officials to determine what the officials know about human rights and environmental problems at the vast Grasberg mine, which contains the richest gold deposit on earth.
    • Freeport spokesman Garland Robinette downplayed the ruling, telling the New Orleans Times-Picayune, "This is strictly a procedural thing in the courts. It has nothing to do with the issues in the suit." Indeed, while the ruling is a win for Alomang, who allegedly was tortured for several weeks by Indonesian soldiers stationed at the mine site, it could be years before her claims ever go before a jury. But it appears the ruling could hasten settlement negotiations between Freeport and tribal leaders.
    • Meanwhile, newspapers in Jakarta, Singapore, and Australia all have carried stories over the past month questioning the links between Freeport and the corrupt regime of former Indonesian president Suharto. Freeport held a press conference July 10 in Jakarta to deny allegations of impropriety. An Agence France Presse story reports Freeport-Indonesia president Adrianto Machribie "decried as `false and misleading' newspaper accounts that suggested Suharto and his associates had improper links with the company."
    • The article also detailed the transaction which allowed the PT Nusamba Company - 80% of which is owned by foundations controlled by Suharto - to buy a 4.7% stake in the Freeport mine. Freeport financed Nusamba's loan for the purchase, something Freeport calls a commonly practiced business deal.
  • Rape in Aceh. Banda Aceh, Indonesia, AFP, July 28, 1998. "Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) have told a parliamentary group investigating violence in this autonomous Indonesian region that some 600 women had been raped over the past seven years, many allegedly by the military, a source said Tuesday."

  • Lorentz National Park closed for mining. Kompas Online, 31 July 1998. "The Minister of Forestry and Plantations, Muslimin Nasution, have agreed to demands of non-government agencies (NGO) to declare the Lorentz National Park a closed area for exploratory activities or mineral exploitations."
  • Soldiers murder in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Gerry van Klinken, Inside Indonesia, No. 55 July-September 1998. The report is available from ACFOA Human Rights, 124 Napier St, Fitzroy 3065, fax 03-9416 2746, acfoahr@acfoa.asn.au. Gerry van Klinken edits 'Inside Indonesia'. "Indonesian soldiers shot at least 11 civilians in the remote interior of Irian Jaya (West Papua), a new report has established. The soldiers were anxious to reestablish government control after they forced OPM rebels to release foreign hostages in May 1996. To permit negotiations during the five months hostage crisis, the Indonesian army had withdrawn from the area."
  • "Untouchable" general faces military trial. Jenny Grant, Sydney Morning Herald, August 4, 1998. Prabowo in trouble.
  • Army apologises and promises troops out of Aceh. Maskur Abdullah, Lhokseumawe, Indonesia. Sydney Morning Herld, August 8, 1998.
  • Military No Longer Keeps Pursuing Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s Trouble-makers. Antara, August 10, 1998. "Manokwari, Irian Jaya (West Papua) - The military will no longer give an emphasis on pursuing security disturbance groups in Irian Jaya (West Papua) but will instead focus their activities on improving the people's welfare in the country's eastern-most province, chief of the Trikora regional military command, Maj Gen Amir Sembiring, said Saturday. ... In this connection, he said PT.Freeport Indonesia, one of the world's biggest gold mining company, has pledged to finance the development of 14 villages in the province's mountainous areas."
  • Indonesian riots: Junior police jailed for killings. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, August 13, 1998.
  • Massacre in Biak. August 7, 1998. Note: This report is disputed. Subsequent claims by the military assert that the bodies washed ashore came from the recent PNG tidal wave.
  • Murder, rape propol Indonesia toward chaos. Dennis J. Coday, National Catholic Reporter, Aug. 14, 1998, p. 12. Grim report on the state organization behind the anti-Chinese violence of May in Jakarta. "According to a Jesuit priest involved with gathering testimony, the systematic violence and violent intimidation continues against the Chinese community and individuals investigating the violence." Rumor of disaster at Lake Wanagon on Freeport site
  • Mine shut down during labor dispute. August 11, 1998. Freeport press release. Mine reopened. August 14, 1998. Freeport press release.
  • Aceh graves prove civilians massacred, rights commission finds. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, August 24, 1998.
  • Jakarta sacks army top brass over kidnappings. Louise Williams, Sydney Morning Herald, August 25, 1998. Suharto's general son-in-law removed!
  • More troops leave. Antara, August 30, 1998. 394 soldiers in Timika have been moved to other assignments.
  • Indonesian Panel: PT Freeport Profit-Sharing Unfair To Locals. Dow Jones Newswires, AP, Sept. 3, 1998. "A parliament commission said Thursday that PT Freeport Indonesia, which operates a huge gold and copper mine in Indonesia's western New Guinea, hasn't done enough to share its profits with local people and, therefore, its operations there should be re-evaluated. The conclusion came from a study by Commission VIII of the 500-member House during a visit the remote region early this month."
  • Parliament commission sheds doubt on mining company's benefits. AP Worldstream, Lexis-Nexis, Sept. 3, 1998. "A parliament commission said Thursday that PT Freeport Indonesia which operates a huge gold and copper mine in Indonesia's western New Guinea, has not proved enough of a benefit to the local people. A study by the group, following a visit to the remote region last month, recommended that the government should study whether it was worth having the company in the country."
  • Government Agrees to Declare Lorentz National Park World Heritage Site. Antara, September 18, 1998.
      "JAYAPURA, Irian Jaya (West Papua) - The Forestry and Plantation Ministry has approved a plan to declare the Lorentz National Park in Indonesia's easternmost province of Irian Jaya (West Papua) as a World Heritage Site, a local environmentalist organisation official said here Thurday.

      The ministry was also calling on the public everywhere to conserve the area which is endowed with one of the rarest ecosystems in the world, said August Rumansara, World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) coordinator for Eastern Indonesia. The Irian the Jaya governor, local customary institute leaders, church leaders, NGO activists and the press had thrown their weight behind the plan, he said."

  • Shell game. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, September 25, 1998. "An explosion that killed three people at a Shell Oil plant in Ohio four years ago has suddenly become an issue in The Austin Chronicle's effort to obtain federal government documents under the Freedom of Information Act."
  • Hand in Glove: How Suharto's Circle, Mining Firm Did So Well Together. Peter Waldman, The Wall Street Journal, September 29, 1998. (Republished in the Austin American Statesman, October 4, 1998.) (Freeport replies to the Wall Street Journal.)
      "Between 1991 and 1997, Freeport made at least $673 million of loan guarantees to three Indonesians with close ties to Mr. Suharto or his ministers. One of those loans helped one of the Indonesians turn a one-year profit of 500% on his $40 million investment -- and helped Freeport renew a crucial mining license. Suharto allies, including at least one cabinet minister, bought assets from the company, such as housing and a hotel near the mine, in deals that Freeport not only helped finance, but in which the company also guaranteed buyers sizable annual profits. In another deal, Freeport not only guaranteed debt, but also agreed to subsidize interest payments for a Suharto- family business partner, enabling him to buy 4.7% of Freeport's Indonesian unit."

      "Concerned about U.S. anticorruption laws, Freeport's lawyers and lenders were wary of the terms extended to such a close Suharto partner, Mr. Moffett says. The company that bought the shares, called PT Nusamba Mineral Industri, was 100%-owned by PT Nusantara Ampera Bakti. The parent, known as Nusamba, is widely accepted in Indonesia as being controlled by the Suharto family. Mr. Hasan himself has said in interviews that Nusamba is 80%-owned by three Suharto-chaired foundations, 10%-owned by his eldest son, and 10%-owned by Mr. Hasan."

  • Jakarta calls halt to military crackdown in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Andrew Marshall, Sydney Morning Herald, October 5, 1998.
  • Freeport FOIA follow-up. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, October 9, 1998. "The Wall Street Journal story provides a road map for regulators at the Securities and Exchange Commission, who now have plenty of evidence to pursue a long-overdue investigation of Freeport under the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act."
  • Indonesia bans American professor. JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) October 16, 1998. -- "Indonesia banned an American college professor from visiting the country after he reportedly alleged that its top economics minister had been involved in a shady business deal. ... Jeffrey Winters, a political economy professor at Northwestern University in Evanston, Ill., ``is not allowed to set foot on Indonesian soil before clearing up his insulting remark against the state official,'' Justice Minister Muladi told the official Antara news agency. ... The reports said Winters accused Ginandjar, a former mines minister, of being involved in a share deal between a local company and PT Freeport Indonesia, a subsidiary of New Orleans-based Freeport McMoRan Copper and Gold Inc."
  • Soeharto pressure mounting. Greg Earl, Australian Financial Review, October 19, 1998. "Meanwhile, tensions appear to be calming over the corruption allegations surrounding the Coordinating Minister for Economics, Dr Ginandjar Kartasasmita, and the approval of the Freeport McMoRan copper mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Last week the Government banned US academic Dr Jeffrey Winters from entering the country and threatened to prosecute him after he repeated long-running speculation about whether Dr Ginandjar benefited from approving the mine when he was Minister for Mines. While the government action appeared to reflect strong support for Dr Ginandjar, it could have been supported by his rivals because the controversy has only serve to highlight the corruption allegations and weaken Dr Ginandjar as a future national leadership candidate."
  • Massacre at dawn. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, Novemer 14, 1998. Slaughter of perhaps 100 Irian Jaya (West Papua) residents by Indonesian troops. Torture, rape, body dismemberment. (An event that occurred in July, but has largely been suppressed until now.) Follow up.
  • Shades of Soeharto in Jakarta round-up. Louise Williams and Lindsay Murdoch. End of the facade of democracy in post-Soeharto Indonesia. More.
  • Moffett testifies, MSNBC, November 15, 1998.
  • Soeharto clan controls vast tracts of Irian. Indonesian Observer, November 18, 1998. "The wealth of Soeharto’s cronies in Irian Jaya (West Papua) is believed to be mostly invested in enterprises serving as contractors to PT Freeport Indonesia, one of the world's largest gold and copper mining companies. For instance, a prominent Soeharto crony, Muhammad "Bob" Hasan, apparently held a virtual monopoly on the supply of food and various other necessities for employees of PT Freeport Indonesia. Before Bob Hasan got his hand on the Freeport food contract, the supplies for the mining firm's employees were handled by local Irian Jaya people or were imported from Australia, Sidabutar said."
  • Massacre in West Papua: A first-hand account. Mike Head, 20 November 1998. MORE!.
  • Mining Company Fills a Hole: U.S. Firm Funds Social Services in Isolated Indonesian Province. Keith B. Richburg, Washington Post, November 30, 1998. "With Freeport's presence, Irian Jaya (West Papua) -- and its 2 million people -- should be one of the wealthiest provinces in the Indonesian archipelago. Yet it remains among the poorest and least developed."
  • 5,000 ABN Amro Clients Sign Protest Against U.S.'s Freeport. Dow Jones News Service, December 17, 1998. "Around 5,000 clients of Dutch banking group ABN Amro Holding NV (AAN) have signed a petition protesting Freeport-McMoran Copper & Gold Inc.'s (FCX) mining activities in Indonesia, for which the bank is one of the financers, ABN said Thursday. ... ABN's management said it has, in light of Milieudefensie's actions, called on Freeport to reach agreement with environmental organizations and the indigenous people of Indonesia's Irian Jaya (West Papua) province, the site of the mines, to conduct an independent study on the impact of Freeport's operations. ... ABN's director general for international loans, Herman Mulder, said that next year Freeport will conduct an independent study on the social and environmental impact of the mining operations."
  • A Suharto relative turns up in Jordan. Associated Press, December 22, 1998. Lt. Gen. Prabowo Subianto, Suharto's son-in-law, was granted citizenship in Jordan on Dec. 10.
  • Indonesia: Human rights and pro-independence actions in Irian Jaya (West Papua). Human Rights Watch, December 28, 1998.
  • Freeport obtains Indonesian approval to expand world's largest gold mine. Mike Head, World Socialist Web Site, 20 February 1999.
  • Trial court rules against Freeport. Tapol, March 1, 1998.
  • Freeport in Sri Lanka.
  • ? AND THE MYSTERIANS. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Vol. 18, Issue 37, May 14-20, 1999.
      Next came critics representing the Seattle Mennonite Church, Christian Brothers (a Catholic order), and Project Underground, a California-based environmental group, all of whom threw darts at the company. Michelle Chan, who represented the Catholic order, said that a pending human rights lawsuit brought against Freeport by local indigenous people "is an example of how the company has failed to address management issues. Why did relations degenerate to the point where the company is facing a $6 billion lawsuit?" she asked. The lawsuit, currently pending in state court in New Orleans, was filed by local tribal leaders in 1996. Adkerson told Chan the lawsuit is "without merit and [we] are confident the court will agree with that."

  • Rape and Other Human Rights Abuses by the Indonesian Military in Irian Jaya (West Papua) (West Papua), Indonesia. Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Center for Human Rights and the Institute for Human Rights Studies and Advocacy, May, 1999.
  • INCIDENTS of MILITARY VIOLENCE AGAINST INDIGENOUS WOMEN in Irian Jaya (West Papua) (WEST PAPUA), INDONESIA. A Report by the Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Center for Human Rights and the Institute for Human Rights Studies and Advocacy, May 1999.
  • Jakarta threatens freedom group, Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herald, May 22, 1999. "A senior Indonesian official has warned that security forces will take "a suppressive approach" if the rebel Free Papua Organisation in Irian Jaya (West Papua) attempts to stage an alternative poll on independence alongside Indonesia's parliamentary elections next month."
  • Sham 'Act of Choice' brought 30 years of bondage. Ben Bohane, Sydney Morning Herald, May 29, 1999.
  • Freeport's Lode of Trouble. Time, June 7, 1999.
  • Freeport's Lode of Trouble: The U. S. company's link to ousted Indonesian President Suharto could jeopardize its primary mining operation. Adam Zagorin. Time, June 7, 1999, p. 62. "If the reform minded parties capture the majority of votes, as looks likely, and the military does not intervene, which seems plausible, popular resentment over the company's connections with Suharto might encourage the new government to re-evaluate even the revised contracts, or to further jack up royalty payments, just as copper prices seem to be turning up."
  • Cunningham calls it quits for UT System. Matthew Hempel, Daily Texan, Jule 11, 1999. "UT System Chancellor William Cunningham announces Thursday that he will retire effective August 31, 2000."
  • Biak massacre verified. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, July 13, 1999.
  • 100 West Papuans killed in 1996 hostage retaliation
  • SAS-Kopassus mounted joint hostage operation. Tapol, July, 1999.
  • Team to investigate Irian Jaya (West Papua) rights abuses. Jakarta Post, 6 August 1999. "An independent team to investigate human rights abuses in Irian Jaya (West Papua) will be set up by the National Commission on Human Rights, members said here on Thursday."
  • Mark Davis investigates allegations about the role of the International Red Cross and the British military in a massacre in the Southern Highlands of Irian Jaya in May 1996. Australian Broadcasting Company, July, 1999.
  • Beanal travel banned. The principal spokeman for the Amungme has been banned from international travel by the Indonesian government. August, 1999.
  • Irianese living in fear, says rights commission. The Jakarta Post, 10 August 1999. "Members of the National Commission on Human Rights concluded from their visit here the Irianese lived in fear."
  • Ruling From the Bench. Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle, Vol. 18, Issue 49, August 6, 1999. "On July 28, U.S. District Judge James Nowlin ruled that the Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC) must release to The Austin Chronicle a 1995 environmental report done by an independent consulting company on Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold's Indonesian mining operation, a report which led the federal agency to cancel a $100 million political risk insurance policy held by Freeport."
  • Human Rights Panel Protests Beanal Travel Ban, Jakarta Post, 7 August, 1999, "JAYAPURA, Irian Jaya (West Papua): The National Commission on Human Rights has protested the Directorate General of Immigration's travel ban on four Irianese leaders and a journalist. "
  • Moses Kilangin Tebnak, Amumgme leader. Press release by John Ondawame, August 18, 1999.
  • How Canberra helped crush freedom quest. Antony Balmain, Sydney Morning Herald, August 26, 1999.
  • Jakarta's bloody hands: military back killings. Sydney Morning Herald, September 9, 1999. "The Indonesian military - presented to the world as providing security while East Timor prepares for independence - is in fact orchestrating the brutal campaign of killings and intimidation, according to secret United Nations assessments."
  • Thousands In Indonesia Army Desert To Join Fray. Keith B. Richburg, Washington Post Service, International Herald Tribune, Tuesday, September 7, 1999. "JAKARTA - As the bloodletting in East Timor worsened, diplomats and military analysts said Monday that they had received new evidence that thousands of East Timorese members of the Indonesian Army and national police had deserted their units, and had effectively joined the militias in their violent rampage."
  • Rape used over and over as a systematic torture. Sydney Morning Herald, 13 September, 1999. "Rape, according to a report released this year by Ms Radhika Coomaraswamy, the United Nations Special Rapporteur on violence against women, has been systematically used by elements of the Indonesian military in East Timor, Aceh and Irian Jaya (West Papua)."
  • Irian Jaya (West Papua) clashes leave 14 dead. October 1, 1999, AFP. "A second day of clashes between local tribesmen and migrants in the mining town of Timika in Indonesia's remote Irian Jaya (West Papua) province killed four people, raising the death toll in two days to 14, reports and a tribal activist said Friday."
  • Irian divided into three. Jakarta Post, October 13, 1999. "Acting Minister of Home Affairs Feisal Tanjung installed Abraham Oktavianus Atururi as West Irian governor, Herman Monim as Central Irian Jaya (West Papua) governor and Suratmin as North Maluku governor. Under a government bill, Maluku will be split into two provinces of North and South Maluku, and Irian Jaya into three provinces of West, East and Central Irian Jaya (West Papua)."
  • East Timor becomes a new state. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, October 20, 1999.
  • Wahid, not Megawati, becomes President of Indonesia. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, October 21, 1999.
  • Megawati elected VP. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, October 22, 1999.
  • CREF Shareholder Meeting Participant Proposal against Freeport-McMoRan. For the CREF meeting, November 9, 1999.
  • Anti-Freeport demo at UT Austin. Press release. Friday, October 29, 1999.

  • Protest targets Jim Bob Moffett. Angel Entzming, Daily Texan, November 1, 1999. "Two Austinites were arrested Friday for throwing algae on the UT molecular biology building during a protest of alleged environmental and human rights abuses in Indonesia."
  • No Laughing Matter, Robert Bryce, Austin Chronicle November 5, 1999. Reports on arrests during the recent Moffett building protest.
  • Minister to close firms damaging environment. Indonesian Observer, November 9, 1999. "State Minister for the Environment, Sony Keraf, has said that the government will not hesitate to close companies which have damaged the environment, and is likely to revoke an existing recommendation allowing the import of industrial waste from Singapore to the provinces of Riau and South Sumatra. ... The Minister said that he would set up a team to investigate environmental problems which are caused by a pulp factory, Inti Indorayon Utama, in North Sumatra, mining company, PT Freeport Indonesia in Irian Jaya (West Papua), and the one-million-hectare peat land project in Central Kalimantan. 'If they are found guilty of damaging the environment, the government will not hesitate to close the companies immediately,' Keraf said."
  • Irian Jaya (West Papua) has a dream: it may become a nightmare. Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herarld, December 1, 1999. "In Timika, on the south side of Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s rugged mountainous spine and close to the huge Freeport-McMoran copper and gold mine, 27 tent ''embassies'' representing tribal groups from across the territory occupy the grounds of the local Catholic church, which is festooned with Morning Star flags and a sign over the gate saying in English: ''God will deliver our land unto us.'' Every night, warriors from the Ndani and Nduga tribes have sung war songs while others have paraded in full traditional regalia to salute the flag. Foreign visitors are required to present their passports to the protest secretariat in bizarre mimicry of an immigration procedure."
  • Thousands raise flag of independence at dawn. Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herarld, December 2, 1999. "Across the province an estimated 20,000 people declared their support for independence, a move that would have seen a military crackdown under previous Indonesian governments."
  • Police open fire on separatists. Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herarld, December 3, 1999. "Witnesses and human rights representatives said trucks carrying Indonesian army (TNI) troops drove to the centre of Timika, near the giant Freeport copper and gold mine, at dawn. They allegedly sealed all exits to the grounds of the town's Catholic church, where protests calling for independence from Indonesia have been held for the past month. Demonstrators were then herded into the grounds. From about 7.30am troops fired on the crowd intermittently for about 20 minutes, witnesses said. A helicopter was also involved in the operation."
  • Protesters refuse to shun independence flag. Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herarld, December 4, 1999. "However, local people produced bullets extracted from the wounds of the injured as evidence the shooting occurred. ''They are liars,'' said one woman who witnessed the shooting. ''They tell the outside world lies''."
  • European Parliament Resolution. December 16, 1999. "Asks the Indonesian Government to bring to account those responsible for violations of human rights in Aceh, the Moluccan Islands, West Papua as well as other parts of the country, and in East Timor, whether committed by civilians, militias or the military ..."
  • "FCX Announces Results of Independent Environmental Audit". Freeport-McMoRan Press Release, December 22, 1999.
  • U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Affirms Dismissal of Beanal Lawsuit. Freeport-McMoRan's mining operations do not violate International Law.. Freeport-McMoRan Press Release, December 1, 1999.
  • Wahid: I'm sorry for abuses. Sydney Morning Herald, January 3, 2000. "President Abdurrahman Wahid, on a visit to the restive province of Irian Jaya (West Papua), has publicly apologised for years of human rights abuse in Indonesia. ... "I am officially conveying my apology for the human rights violations in Papua, Aceh, Ambon and other provinces," he said at a meeting with religious and civic leaders in Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s capital, Jayapura, on Friday. He also agreed to change Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s name officially to Papua, an ethnic name for the Melanesian nation inhabiting the New Guinea island."
  • Helicopter help for Indonesian troops 'normal'. Peter Cole-Adams, Sydney Morning Herald, January 7, 2000. (The Australian mining firm Newcrest helping with Indonesian bloodshed?) "The Indonesian news agency Antara reported claims by a local Muslim group, the Holy War Force, that they had seen the helicopter ferrying arms, personnel and ammunition for use by Christians."
  • Jakarta's Grip Is Slipping. Michael Richardson, International Herald Tribune, January 10, 2000. "The Indonesian military, discredited by widespread human rights abuses and overstretched by having to deal with multiple separatist and sectarian conflicts, may no longer be able or willing to control the forces that threaten to fragment the world's fourth most populous nation, some officers and analysts say."
  • Wahid 'preparing to sack Wiranto'. Sydney Morning Herald, January 17, 2000. "On Friday, the US Ambassador to the United Nations, Mr Richard Holbrooke, warned Indonesia's military to conform to civilian rule or face economic collapse, political isolation and pursuit by an international war crimes tribunal. Mr Holbrooke's blunt warning reflected growing US concern that the armed forces might seek to topple Mr Wahid rather than submit to an investigation of war crimes in East Timor last year."
  • Soeharto forces 'building militias'. Andrew Kilvert, Sydney Morning Herald. "Military authorities and political enforcers associated with the former Soeharto regime appear to be building up East Timor-style militias in the contested province of West Papua, human rights activists warned yesterday."
  • Indonesia's draft law on human rights court will protect generals from justice . Tapol, January 24, 2000.
  • TESTING THE FAITH; Muslim-Christian violence rampant in 'new' Indonesia; Fifth most-populous nation explodes with religious hatred. Anthony C. LoBaido, World Net Daily, January 24, 2000. "When the TMI invaded Timor in 1975," he said, "Henry Kissinger was in Jakarta the day before the invasion, presumably to give the go-ahead. ..."
  • New laws 'could stop trials of military officers'. Karen Polglaze, Sydney Morning Herald, January 26, 2000.
  • Indonesia's Wahid says he will sack top general linked to E.Timor violence. CNN, January 31, 2000.
  • UNITED NATIONS OFFICE OF THE HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS; REPORT OF THE INTERNATIONAL COMMISSION OF INQUIRY ON EAST TIMOR TO THE SECRETARY-GENERAL. Sydney Morning Herald, February 2, 2000.
  • Govt told to review Freeport deal. Jakarta Post, February 2, 2000. "The House of Representatives asked the government on Tuesday to review its contract with mining company PT Freeport Indonesia, saying the deal violated investment regulations and the 1945 State Constitution. The recommendation was announced by House commissions I and II following a visit to Irian Jaya (West Papua) during the recess in December of last year. ... The two commissions concluded in their report that the mining operations had resulted in socioeconomic injustice, rampant human rights abuse and political tension."
  • The UN's former role in Irian Jaya (West Papua). John Saltford, opinion piece Jakarta Post, February 8, 2000. "Recently declassified United Nations documents shed new light on an episode from the 1960s which should serve as a warning to the organization today. ... One can argue that Indonesia, like all states, was simply pursuing what it considered to be its own national interest. The UN, however, is supposed to have higher standards of behavior. Thirty years later, it is time for a re-examination of U Thant's role in the denial of Irianese self-determination. (Comment by rsb: that the Jakarta Post can print such a piece is a stunning proof of freedom of the press in Indonesia at the moment.)
  • For Moffett and Freeport, the storm eases up. Ralph K. M. Haurwitz, Austin American-Statesman, February 13, 2000, p. H1. "Freeport adopted a rare corporate policy a year ago requiring employees to certify annually whether they participated in or witnessed violations of human rights. And in November, Gabrielle Kirk McDonald, a member of Freeport's board who recently stepped down as president of the war crimes tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, was appointed special counsel on human rights for the company. ... (The Texas Supreme Court) is expected to rule any day on Austin's challenge of a state law -- enacted after a lobbying blitz by Freeport in 1995 -- that removes Stratus from the city's regulatory jurisdiction. Status, which previously was controlled by Freeport is now independent, and Moffett said he no longer holds shares in the Austin-based real estate development company. ... There was no ribbon-cutting for the Louise and James Robert Moffett Molecular Biology Building when it opened in 1997. Perhaps because of campus politics, few people use the Moffett name when referring to it. Even the university's maps and Web site identify it simply as the molecular biology building."
  • AWPA Newsletter, No. 2, February 2000.
  • Wiranto defiant: I will not resign. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, February 2, 2000.
  • Indonesian General Suspended. JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) "In a surprise reversal, President Abdurrahman Wahid suspended his powerful security minister, Gen. Wiranto, from the Cabinet over his alleged role in last year's bloodshed in East Timor, newspapers reported Monday." AP-NY-02-13-00 2007EST
  • Wiranto stays in Cabinet as Wahid backs down. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, February 14, 2000.
  • Wiranto goes out with a whimper as Wahid finally acts. Lindsay Murdoch, February 15, 2000. Sydney Morning Herald.
  • Freeport Indonesia May be Shut Down for Pollution. Asia Pulse, February 11, 2000. "State Minister for Environment Sonny Keraf says he will recommend the closure of Freeport Indonesia if the US copper mining company operating in Irian Jaya (West Papua), is found to have caused environmental pollution."
  • Under Attack at Home, Indonesia's Military Reels. Seth Mydans, New York Times, February 13, 2000. "As the joke had it, if someone steps on your toe in the bus, you say to him: 'Are you a member of the military? If not, please get off my toe.' ... With the forced resignation of Mr. Suharto nearly two years ago and the powerful momentum of a nationwide reform movement, the military is retreating in disarray from its commanding position in society."
  • 1999 Report of the Office for Justice and Peace of the Diocese of Jayapura .
  • Amnesty International/RFK Memorial Center for Human Rights Critique of Freeport McMoRan 1999 Social & Human Rights Policy , 1999. See also the full report.
  • U.S. Resumes Training Indonesian Army Officers, Washington Post, February 18, 2000.
  • U.S. backs Indonesian territorial integrity. The Jakarta Post, February 18, 2000. "Despite Washington's support for East Timorese independence last year, the United States does not back any of the other movements seeking to cut ties with Indonesia, the U.S. State Department said Wednesday. ... Del. Eni Maleomavaega, a Democratic member of Congress who represents American Samoa, took issue with (Assistant Secretary of State Stanley) Roth, particularly in reference to Irian Jaya (West Papua). He suggested that Indonesia does not have a legitimate claim to the region because of ethnic and linguistic differences and other reasons. ... Roth testified before the House International Relations Asia-Pacific subcommittee."
  • The Next East Timor. Ben Bohane, The Australian Magazine, Feb 19-20, 2000.
  • A brief summary of the past year in West Papua. Australia West Papua Association, Sydney.
  • Amdal on Freeport examined. The Jakarta Post English Edition, February 21, 2000. MAKASSAR, South Sulawesi (JP): "State Minister of Environment Sonny Keraf said his office would audit, and perhaps redo, the environmental impact analysis (Amdal) of copper and gold mining company PT Freeport Indonesia as the analysis report contained several irregularities. 'Based on queries by an auditing team of the Environmental Impact Management Agency (Bapedal) from the ministry's office, we found several irregularities in their environmental impact analysis,' Sonny told journalists here on Saturday."
  • West Papua's 1969 `referendum' re-visited . Tapol, the Indonesia Human Rights Campaign Bulletin Online 156 - Jan/Feb 2000. "One British diplomat commented in April 1968:

    The strength of the Indonesian position lies in the fact that....they must know that, even if there are protests about the way they go through the motions of consultation, no other power is likely to conceive it as being in their interests to intervene. There will be protests from the Papuan exiles in Holland, Japan and at the United Nations. I understand that the exiles may find some support in the Australian press. But I cannot imagine the US, Japanese, Dutch or Australian Governments putting at risk their economic and political relations with Indonesia on a matter of principle involving a relatively small number of very primitive people."

  • Jakarta's thugs in red berets finally brought to account. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, February 23, 2000. "But the new civilian government in Jakarta is preparing to effectively dismantle Kopassus, the country's 6,000-strong elite red beret special force that human rights investigators say is behind a swathe of terrorist acts across the archipelago over decades, including last year's violence in East Timor and atrocities in Aceh province."
  • Sonny business as Freeport feels the heat. Tim Dodd, Australian Financial Review, February 22, 2000. "Mr Keraf's latest target is the giant Freeport copper and gold mine in Irian Jaya, which after strong criticism of its environmental and community relations record, has been labouring hard in recent years to demonstrate it is a good corporate citizen. ... But Mr Keraf zeroed in on the weakest point of the company's environmental record - the tens of millions of tonnes of tailings which Freeport pours into the wild mountain rivers each year at its mine site, almost 4,500 metres high among the glaciers of Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s highest mountain range. ... Mr Keraf said the answers he had received to queries about the environmental impact statement were not adequate. 'Freeport needs to explain many things, such as its environmental working plans and the dumping of tailings from the mine,' he said."
  • West Papua's 1969 `referendum' re-visited . Tapol, the Indonesia Human Rights Campaign Bulletin Online 156 - Jan/Feb 2000. "One British diplomat commented in April 1968:

    The strength of the Indonesian position lies in the fact that....they must know that, even if there are protests about the way they go through the motions of consultation, no other power is likely to conceive it as being in their interests to intervene. There will be protests from the Papuan exiles in Holland, Japan and at the United Nations. I understand that the exiles may find some support in the Australian press. But I cannot imagine the US, Japanese, Dutch or Australian Governments putting at risk their economic and political relations with Indonesia on a matter of principle involving a relatively small number of very primitive people."

  • 1999 U. S. State Department Report on Indonesia.

    GUS DUR: DON'T SELL PAPUA'S FUTURE TO HENRY KISSINGER. Comments by Emmy Hafild, Executive Director of WALHI-Indonesian Forum for Environment, on Henry Kissinger's increasing involvement with Indonesia.

  • GUS DUR: DON'T SELL PAPUA'S FUTURE TO HENRY KISSINGER. Comments by Emmy Hafild, Executive Director of WALHI-Indonesian Forum for Environment, on Henry Kissinger's increasing involvement with Indonesia.
  • Walhi protests Kissinger’s Freeport statement. Indonesian Observer, March 1, 2000. "JAKARTA, A leading environmental group yesterday slammed former US secretary of state Henry Kissinger for urging Indonesia not to review business deals with giant copper and mining company PT Freeport Indonesia. The Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi) said the statement was a form of "intimidation" against the Indonesian government considering that Freeport Indonesia was accused of pollution in Irian Jaya, where the company is based."
  • President asks Freeport to heed local aspirations. Indonesian Observer, February 29, 2000. "JAKARTA, President Abdurrahman Wahid said yesterday Indonesia will respect contract agreements with PT Freeport Indonesia, but he expressed the wish that the company will help the government to fulfill the people’s aspirations. President Wahid’s statement was made when meeting with Henry Kissinger, a former US secretary of state and a board member of Freeport McMoRan, in the Bina Graha presidential office here yesterday."
  • Jakarta's thugs in red berets finally brought to account. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, February 23, 2000. "But the new civilian government in Jakarta is preparing to effectively dismantle Kopassus, the country's 6,000-strong elite red beret special force that human rights investigators say is behind a swathe of terrorist acts across the archipelago over decades, including last year's violence in East Timor and atrocities in Aceh province."
  • Indonesia Sets up Team to Probe Freeport in March. Asia Pulse, February 29, 2000. "A fact finding team will start work early March to investigate charges against PT Freeport Indonesia, a U.S. copper and gold mining company in Irian Jaya. Mines and Energy Minister Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono said he had talked with the company leaders on the plan to send the team to Irian Jaya to investigate the charges that the company had caused environmental damage and failed to comply with its contract."
  • Kissinger calls on RI to honor Freeport deal. Jakarta Post, February 29, 2000. "JAKARTA (JP): Former U.S. secretary of state Henry Kissinger called on the Indonesian government to honor its contract with copper and gold mining enterprise PT Freeport Indonesia amid growing criticism over the company's mining activities. Kissinger, listed on the company's website as a member of the board of directors of the U.S. parent company, Freeport McMoRan, warned that any violation of the contract would have an impact on the flow of foreign investment into the country."
  • Indonesia Environment Min Wants A Review On Freeport. JAKARTA (Dow Jones/March 3)--Indonesian Environment Minister Sonny Keraf said Friday the government should review the mining contract of gold and copper miner PT Freeport Indonesia over its environmental record in connection to its operations in the Indonesian province of Irian Jaya. "Personally, I think the Freeport contract should be reviewed to (further efforts to) conserve the environment (near its mining site)," he told reporters.
  • Indonesia May Take Freeport to Court If Found Corrupt. Asia Pulse, March 2, 2000. "US gold and copper mining company PT Freeport Indonesia may be brought to court if it proves to have committed corruptive and collusive practices in winning its work contract, People's Consultative Assembly (MPR) chairman Amien Rais said Wednesday."
  • The government asks concessions from Freeport. Kompas Online, March 3, 2000. "The Indonesian government decided to submit concessions from PT Freeport Indonesia in relation with the Work Contract that is going on. The concessions are chosen with considering profit and loss instead of reviewing the contract. It is feared that that will exactly cause foreign investors to transfer their investment. Thus said the Foreign Affairs minister Alwi Shihab in Yogyakarta, Thursday (2/3)."
  • Call for Probe of Freeport Indonesia by Independent Auditor JAKARTA, March 3 Asia Pulse/Antara - An independent auditor should carry out due diligence of Freeport Indonesia to put an end to controversies surrounding the US copper and gold mining company, the Indonesian Transparency Community (ITC). ITC secretary Erry Riyana H. said due diligence would show the company's financial contribution to Indonesia and the amount of natural wealth it has taken away from the country. Freeport Indonesia has been accused of colluding with government officials in securing its contract of work. It has also been blamed for causing extensive damage to the environment in its mining area in Irian Jaya.
  • JOINT STATEMENT BY VICTIMS OF THE 1996 HOSTAGE CRISIS IN MAPNDUMA WITH DETAILS OF HUMAN RIGHTS VIOLATIONS IN CENTRAL HIGHLANDS, WEST PAPUA. The statement bears the signatures or thumb prints of 123 people including sixteen women.
  • ACT OF FREE CHOICE PAPUANS WAS A FARCE. NRC Handelsblad (Dutch Newspaper). Via tapol@gn.apc.org. Jayapura/Sucre, March 4, 2000 - In 1969, the Indonesian government manipulated the 'Act of Free Choice' about the status of the former Dutch New Guinea (Irian Jaya). 'By all means, proper or improper', Jakarta wanted to prevent the Papuan people from choosing against final integration into Indonesia. This appears from a so-called 'secret instruction' in May 1969 given by Soemarto, the Indonesian commander in Merauke, to the regent of that area. NRC Handelsblad possesses a copy of this letter in which it is stated that participants to the musyawarah (deliberating popular meetings) must be selected on their loyalty to Indonesia. If there is no loyalty, then 'one has to have the courage to use improper methods to remove the delegates concerned'.
  • : Freeport Contract Must be Amended: Indonesian Minister. JAKARTA, March 6 Asia Pulse/Antara - "The work contract of US gold and copper mining giant PT Freeport Indonesia with the Indonesian government must be amended as it is no longer compatible with the current situation and conditions in the country, State Administrative Reform Minister Freddy Numbery says."
  • : Papua Demands a Stake in Freeport Indonesia. JAKARTA, March 6 Antara/Asia Pulse - "The regional administration of Papua has called for amendment of the working contract of PT Freeport Indonesia to include the province as a shareholder in the U.S. company. Papua Governor Freddy Numberi said the amendment could put an end to frequent disputes between the local people and copper and gold mining company."
  • The Man Who Outran Death. IHT. March 10, 2000.
  • Lured to death by fake Red Cross. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, March 15, 2000.
  • Aceh atrocities 'commonplace'. Sydney Morning Herald, March 15, 2000.
  • Military blasted over 1996 Papua hostage drama. Tapol, March 22, 2000. "Using the (Red Cross) emblem was a serious violation of humanatarian law," Grossieder told reporters in Jakarta."
  • West Papua Govt Wants Half Of Indonesia's Freeport Stock. Dow Jones, March 22, 2000. JAKARTA (Dow Jones)--"The government of West Papua is demanding half of the Indonesian government's 8% equity stake in copper miner PT Freeport Indonesia Company, West Papua Deputy Governor J.R.G. Djopari said Wednesday. 'We want the government to share 50% of its stake in Freeport with the regional government,' Djopari told reporters on the sidelines of a hearing with parliament. He, however, said the West Papua government hasn't filed its demand with the Indonesian government yet, but will do it soon."
  • State Court Dismisses With Prejudice Complaint Against Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc.. Press release, Freeport-McMoRan, 23 March, 2000.
  • Leasing the Ivory Tower at a Social Justice University: Freeport McMoRan, Loyola University, New Orleans and Greenwashing. Julia Fox. " This paper is a case study of the financial ties between Freeport McMoran Corporation and Loyola University, New Orleans. Freeport is a large transnational corporation that has a deplorable domestic and international environmental and human rights record in West Papua. Loyola University is a "social justice" university that is advertised as an independent university that fosters critical thinking This paper examines Freeport's endowment of the Environmental Communication Chair at Loyola and how Freeport constrained the internal operations of the university when faculty and students protested the investment. This paper argues that Freeport's investment in a social justice university provides a public relations function of greenwashing and human rights sterilization."
  • Review of Freeport Audit, via David Ortman, Ex. Director, NW Corporate Accountability Project.
  • A Savage Dawn for the 'Morning Star'?. Dana R. Dillon, The Los Angeles Times, Friday, April 28, 2000. "-- Indonesia: A West Papua independence declaration is likely to provoke new bloodshed. Even before the blood is dry in East Timor, another secessionist crisis looms in Indonesia. On May 1, Theys Hiyo Eluay, the self-proclaimed Great Leader of the Papuan Nation, intends to declare an independent government of West Papua and raise that nascent country's forbidden "Morning Star" flag. This act of defiance to the Indonesian government, which is conducting a major military buildup on the island it shares with Papua New Guinea, could be more savage and protracted than East Timor's secession."
  • WALHI have launched a campaign on Freeport.. May 4, 2000. Down to Earth in England and the International Friends of the Earth have received information on this campaign which have forwarded to us. Details are in the CamPeace webpage. We would appreciate your support and help with the dissemination of this information in Australia and perhaps in the USA/UTexas. You may also note we have set up an eGroup for exchanging information on current events in West Papua and as a medium for coordinating the various campaigns on West Papua. Details are in the same Webpage. http://members.tripod.co.uk/CamPeace/WestPapua.html Yours sincerely, Nick Angelopoulos, Cambridge Campaign for Peace (CamPeace), United Kingdom.
  • Grasberg incident: four missing. Freeport Press Release, May 5, 2000. "PT Freeport Indonesia (PT-FI), today reported an incident that occurred last night at the Grasberg mine overburden stockpile involving the slippage of overburden waste which caused a wave of water and material to overtop the Wanagon basin spillway and enter the Wanagon valley. Four employees of a contractor to PT-FI working in the area are unaccounted for and an intensive search is under way."
  • Mine mishap sweeps four to their deaths. Jay Solomon, Sydney Morning Herald, May 9, 2000.
  • Freeport Agrees To Temporarily Limit Production. Freeport Press Release, May 24, 2000.
  • Freeport-McMoRan suspected of abuses in Indonesia. Jamie Tarabay, Associated Press, Austin American-Statesman, May 26, 2000. p. A2. "Jakarta, Indonesia -- Indonesia's government will ask a new human rights commission to investigate possible abuses by New Orleans-based Freeport-McMoRan Copper and Gold Inc., a government minister said Thursday."
  • Former Indonesian President Suharto placed under house arrest; Prosecutors vow to file embezzlement charges. MSNBC, May 29, 2000.
  • The Indonesian Government is sending military reinforcements to the Moluccan islands following the massacre of at least 50 Christian villagers by Muslim militants.. BBC. May 30, 2000.
  • West Papuans set up government. Andrew Kilvert, Syndney Morning Herald, June 5, 2000. "West Papua yesterday announced the formation of a government and declared independence from Jakarta ... The congress called for crimes against humanity in the province to be investigated and for those involved brought to justice. It named named a tribal chief, Mr Theys Eluai, as chairman of the Papuan People's Presidium and Mr Tom Beanal as deputy chairman."
  • Suharto loses battle with Time. Sydney Morning Herald, June 7, 2000.
  • Why West Papua deserves another chance: The UN ballot in 1969 broke every rule for genuine self-determination. Sam Blay, Inside Indonesia, Jan - Mar, 2000.
  • Gus Dur’s Overseas Trip: Government Gets Support from Kofi Annan on the Matter of Aceh and Papua. Tempo Interactif, June 14, 2000. "In fact, Annan promised Gus Dur that Papua would not be on the agenda of the United Nations."
  • Environment minister blasts Freeport. Indonesian Observer,June 17, 2000. "JAKARTA (IO) Environment Minister Sonny Keraf says the government plans to revoke a permit that allows hugely profitable PT Freeport Indonesia to dump tailings into rivers near the company’s Grasberg gold and copper mine in remote Irian Jaya. ... Some environmentalists fear that Keraf’s effort to get tough on Freeport will have little impact."
  • The Nabire Event. 'Then he was asked, "what is your nationality?" to which he replied, "I am a Papuan." Then he was asked, "are you not an Indonesian?" to which he replied, "my father is a Papuan and my mother is a Papuan, my land is Papuan. I am Papuan." Yance was tehn ordered to sleep on the floor and he was trodden on the chest by a number of members of Brimob wearing combat boots. The police tied plastic around the middle finder of his right hand and set it alight. They also burnt his right shoulder. The torture continued with electric shock treatment to his left hand. Then he was ordered to choose one of the instruments of torture placed before him on the table. Yance chose the pistol. The police asked, "why?" to which he replied, "so that I am dead and become a hero." The Brimob put the barrel of the pistol into his mouth, but they did not shoot.'
  • Papuan Declaration of Independence.
  • *135 killed in village massacre*. Geoff Spencer, Sydney Morning Herald, June 21, 2000.
  • Human Rights Watch Report on Papua, 1999-2000.
  • Navy evacuates 768 terrified Christians. June 23, 2000. South China Morning Post.
  • Thousands flee religious violence in Indonesia's Ambon. June 28, CNN.
  • Hundreds feared drowned. June 29, 2000. CNN. "Hundreds of people were feared dead on Thursday after the sinking of a boat packed with refugees from religious violence in Indonesia's North Maluku province." Cf. SMH. Cf. NYT.
  • *Sinking rupiah is worst currency in world*. Sydney Morning Herald, July 6, 2000.
  • Papua. Lindsay Murdoch, Sydney Morning Herald, July 8, 2000. "Seven Papuan leaders ushered into the presidential palace this week were surprised with the reception they received from Abdurrahman Wahid."
  • AMBON BISHOP ASKS FOR EVACUATION OF 100,000 CHRISTIANS. CWNews.com. July 8, 2000. "At least 100,000 Christians need immediate evacuation because they are in serious danger of being slaughtered by Muslim-jihad troops," said Auxiliary Bishop Jos Tethool of Amboina diocese. ... On Thursday, Bishop Petrus Canisius Mandagi of Amboina, accompanied by leaders of two Protestant churches in the Moluccas, departed for Geneva to request immediate interventions on the part of the United Nations' Security Council and the United Nations' Commission for Human Rights.
  • Indonesia Troops Said Taking Sides. Daniel Cooney, AP, July 19, 2000. "JAKARTA, Indonesia (AP) -- Indonesia's military admitted Tuesday that some of its troops have taken sides in the long-running Christian-Muslim war in the Maluku islands."
  • Indonesia's next East Timor? Julian Evans, The New Statesman, 10 July, 2000. "As for the practicalities of mining in West Papua, there is one further thing to say. In tactical terms it may have been a mistake on Freeport's part to accept the Army's protection so readily. If political moves to secure Papuan independence fail or falter too long, OPM commanders have indicated that their future strategy will concentrate on economic targeting. The company knows its mine (and any future expansion) is vulnerable to guerrilla attack: Grasberg workers are aware, since some were employed there, that to close the profitable Panguna mine on nearby Bougainville island in the early Nineties, all the Bougainville Revolutionary Army had to do was blow up a power plant and murder a couple of expatriates. In such circumstances expatriate enterprise has a low risk threshold (Panguna has not reopened). It is unarguable that without the Indonesian Army's presence and readiness to inflict reprisals, the mighty Grasberg mine would be as exposed as Panguna. And if Grasberg were to go up, it would make Bougainville look like a picnic. Freeport and Rio Tinto cannot say they haven't been warned."
  • Freeport-McMoRan: A Pit of Trouble. Business Week, July 31, 2000.
    • "This year, Freeport put an Amungme chief, Tom Beanal, on the board of Freeport Indonesia, the subsidiary operating the mine."
    • "Gabrielle K. McDonald is the first African American woman to serve as a U.S. District Court judge. For six years, she served on the Bosnia war-crimes tribunal at The Hague. .. In November, McDonald was named special counsel on human rights by Freeport-McMoRan Copper & Gold Inc., ... 'Moffett said he told her: ``Gaby, you have full rein. You make recommendations, and I'll take them.'"
    • "Indeed, local tribes honor deals only as long as the person who made them is ali