Commentary by the National Liberation Council of West Papua, Poptahof-Nrd. 299, 2624 RN Delft, The Netherlands. Tel. 015-2613036, Fax. (15)-2613036. "It is known that Dr. Ortiz Sanz, the United Nations representative for advising, assisting and co-organizing the 'Act of Free choice' in 'West Irian' in 1969, was severely hampered in executing his tasks by the Indonesian government. He was not allowed by the Indonesian government to give advice, nor to assist and co-organize, as it was laid down in article XVII of the 'New York Agreement' of 1962. In addition, he was not allowed to take a large staff (50 people) to 'West Irian' because there was 'no sufficient housing available for those people', according to Indonesia. It was also known that the original content of his final report to the 24th General Assembly of the United Nations in 1969 was not accepted by the Asian Secretary General U Thant, because the wording of the report was too sharp and too negative for Indonesia. Consequently, great pressure was put on Dr. Ortiz Sanz to soften the wording of his final report. Despite this pressure Dr. Ortiz Sanz did maintain some of his original remarks in his revised report so that he was still able to express his criticism and regret openly. It has now become apparent that the appropriation of West Papua (New Guinea) by Indonesia, has been accompanied by all types of deceit and intimidation. Both the Melanisean people of West Papua (New Guinea) and the United National have been deceived."
It is reported that there are also fires in the vast Lorentz National Park, which adjoins the Freeport mine area.
Amungme tribal leader Yosepha Alomang, a mother of 10, should be in Britain. But as she boarded the plane this month in Irian Jaya (West Papua), Indonesia, to head for London and the Rio Tinto annual meeting, she was stopped by the military. Had she come, Ms Alomang would have told the mining firm's corporate shareholders a harrowing tale of torture at the hands of the authorities. Four years ago she was imprisoned without charges, sexually abused and threatened with being shot. Held for a month in a filthy room, she was made to eat her own faeces.
Ms Alomang is one of many outspoken critics of the huge Freeport copper mine, high in the mountains of Irian Jaya (West Papua), which is part-owned by Rio Tinto. For years the mine has been the centre of well-documented human rights violations against indigenous groups. It is also an example of an increasingly common trend that sees governments working in the interests of global corporations, against their own people. The mine subsidises the army by more than $30 million a year, and, like Shell in Nigeria or BP in Colombia, its owners distance themselves from atrocities carried out to "protect" its operation.
In Mealey, op. cit., p. 86 we read "As the first contract of work (1967) under the new Indonesian law, the agreement (the contract of work) broke new ground, Freeport's tax department helped the Indonesian government develop its system for taxing expatriates, something with which it had no experience, even opening its salary books so the tax office could get a general idea of the level of expatriate pay. The good relationship between Freeport and the Indonesian government also established the notion of the primacy of a contract, that the terms of a contract are not affected by future changes in, for example, the Indonesian tax code."
See also Freeport and Busang. Also, "In February, Freeport won an agreement for developing the Busang field with Bre-X and a close associate of President Suharto's." NY Times, April 30, 1997. Also, "Freeport, through Mr. Moffett's connections with Indonesian President Suharto, was brought into the Busang project as mine developer and manager after a deal with Toronto-based Barrick Gold Corp. fell through." Ottawa Citizen, April 30, 1997.
"Moffet arrived in Timika on Friday night after meeting President Suharto earlier in Jakarta." AFP, April 13, 1996.
"Early this year, according to The Financial Times of London, a company that is 80 percent owned by 'foundations' chaired by President Suharto bought a five percent interest in the mine, Suharto's government has long owned nine percent directly." Mark Bowen, Climbing Magazine, Nov. 1, 1997.
"At a recent dinner celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Asia Society (a nonprofit organization dedicated to fostering understanding between Asians and Americans), General Suharto was warmly introduced by one of his leading corporate patrons and beneficiaries, James Robert Moffett, the chief executive officer of Louisiana-based mining company Freeport-McMoRan." Eyal Press, Christian Science Monitor, Nov. 10, 1995, p. 19.
Suharto "sees the Grasberg mine as the cornerstone of his eastern Indonesia development policy. The government has a 10% stake in Freeport Indonesia, with another 5% owned by Nusamba, a Suharto foundation run by presidential ally Mohamad 'Bob' Hasan." John McBeth, Far Eastern Economic Review, December 5, 1997.
"The mine's future was reported to have been raised by President Suharto of Indonesia when he dined at the White House in late October." The Independent on Sunday, 26 Nov 1995, Janine Roberts.
"On Thursday night, Indonesian President Suharto stopped in Washington for a dinner in his honor to benefit CARE, the relief organization. Moffett hosted the dinner. The next morning, Suharto called on President Clinton at the White House. A press release said that the talks focused on lofty subjects, including the Asian economy. But a senior Administration official acknowledged afterward that Suharto urged Clinton to make sure OPIC insurance would be preserved for Freeport-McMoran's Indonesian mining operations." LA Times, October 30, 1995. Includes photo of Suharto and Clinton.
"Since 1983, Freeport's political action committee has paid members of Congress more than $730,000 for their favors. Louisiana's J. Bennett Johnston, the Senate's staunchest advocate of the Suharto regime and of US. oil and mining interests, got $8,000." ... "Jim Bob calls Suharto 'a compassionate man,' and indeed the dictator's tenderness for Freeport is such that he has seen to it that anyone who gets in the company's way is simply removed. About a month after the confrontation between the Amungme chief and the Freeport exec, 2,000 Amungme living near the mining site were ordered to leave their homes by the Indonesian government. It was a familiar action, one in a series of forced removals that began in 1967, when Freeport was granted the right to exploit Irian Jaya (West Papua)'s mineral resources." Eyal Press, The Nation, July 31, 1995. (Johnston is now on the Freeport board.)
"While Bre-X, a small exploration company, has relatively little besides this project, Freeport-McMoran Copper and Gold is an old hand at Indonesian mining and investment. With close ties to the Suharto Government, the company has developed the world's largest copper mine and the third-largest gold mine in Irian Jaya (West Papua), another remote region, along the flanks of a dormant volcano." NY Times, April 29, 1997.
"With close ties to the Suharto Government of Indonesia, Freeport-McMoran Copper and Gold has developed the world's largest copper mine and third-largest gold mine in that nation's remote Irian Jaya (West Papua) region." Allen Myerson, NY Times, July 29, 1997.
"Following the shock announcement that US insurance company OPIC was cancelling Freeport's USD100 million policy against political unrest, it has been revealed that the Indonesian government lobbied hard against this possibility. Without mentioning its sources, Tiras says President Suharto asked President Clinton at their meeting 27 October to prevent the cancellation." Tiras, 16 November 1995.
"The same company whose CEO describes Suharto as his 'partner' opts to make no comment about abuses committed by troops under Suharto's command." Eyal Press, Christian Science Monitor, Nov. 10, 1995.
"Suharto visited Timika in early December to show his support for the embattled company." Far Eastern Economic Review. 25 January 1996.)
The ministry was also calling on the public everywhere to conserve the area which is endowed with one of the rarest ecosystems in the world, said August Rumansara, World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF) coordinator for Eastern Indonesia. The Irian the Jaya governor, local customary institute leaders, church leaders, NGO activists and the press had thrown their weight behind the plan, he said."
"Concerned about U.S. anticorruption laws, Freeport's lawyers and lenders were wary of the terms extended to such a close Suharto partner, Mr. Moffett says. The company that bought the shares, called PT Nusamba Mineral Industri, was 100%-owned by PT Nusantara Ampera Bakti. The parent, known as Nusamba, is widely accepted in Indonesia as being controlled by the Suharto family. Mr. Hasan himself has said in interviews that Nusamba is 80%-owned by three Suharto-chaired foundations, 10%-owned by his eldest son, and 10%-owned by Mr. Hasan."
The strength of the Indonesian position lies in the fact that....they must know that, even if there are protests about the way they go through the motions of consultation, no other power is likely to conceive it as being in their interests to intervene. There will be protests from the Papuan exiles in Holland, Japan and at the United Nations. I understand that the exiles may find some support in the Australian press. But I cannot imagine the US, Japanese, Dutch or Australian Governments putting at risk their economic and political relations with Indonesia on a matter of principle involving a relatively small number of very primitive people."
The strength of the Indonesian position lies in the fact that....they must know that, even if there are protests about the way they go through the motions of consultation, no other power is likely to conceive it as being in their interests to intervene. There will be protests from the Papuan exiles in Holland, Japan and at the United Nations. I understand that the exiles may find some support in the Australian press. But I cannot imagine the US, Japanese, Dutch or Australian Governments putting at risk their economic and political relations with Indonesia on a matter of principle involving a relatively small number of very primitive people."
GUS DUR: DON'T SELL PAPUA'S FUTURE TO HENRY KISSINGER. Comments by Emmy Hafild, Executive Director of WALHI-Indonesian Forum for Environment, on Henry Kissinger's increasing involvement with Indonesia.